← Back to Blog
Retaker Strategy

Why Retakers Should Practice Essays (Even If You Think You Failed the MBE)

April 2026 · 7 min read

Why Retakers Should Practice Essays (Even If You Think You Failed the MBE)

If you failed the bar exam and you're walking into round two assuming the MBE was your problem, you might be working on the wrong half of the test.

This is one of the most common retaker traps. The MBE feels harder while you're taking it because it's a 200-question grind under time pressure with answer choices designed to make you doubt yourself. By the end of MBE day, most takers feel like they failed, regardless of how they actually did.

The MEE feels different. You finish your six essays, you walk out, you feel like at least some of them went okay. Confirmation bias kicks in: "I felt better about the essays, so the MBE must be where I lost it."

That instinct is often wrong. Here's how to tell what actually happened, and why retakers who don't practice essays in their second attempt often fail again for the same reason.

How UBE Scoring Actually Works

The Uniform Bar Examination has three components:

The combined written portion (MEE + MPT) is 50% of your total. The MBE is the other 50%. They're equal in weight.

This is the math that retakers often miss. If you scored a 145 on the MBE (well above the typical 133-135 cut score range) but failed overall, the math is brutally simple: your written score sank you. No amount of additional MBE practice will fix that.

Reading Your Score Report

When you got your fail notice, you also got a score breakdown. Pull it up. You're looking for two numbers:

  1. Your scaled MBE score (typically 100-200, with passing usually around 133-135)
  2. Your scaled written score (combined MEE + MPT)

If your MBE was at or above the passing threshold but your written score was below, the MEE and MPT are where you lost the exam.

Even if both were below passing, the question is which one had more room for improvement. A 130 MBE needs maybe 5 more points. A 115 written score needs 20 more points. The arithmetic tells you where to invest.

Three Signs the MEE Was Your Real Problem

Beyond the score breakdown, there are softer signs that the written portion was your weak spot.

Sign 1: You Finished the MBE on Time

If you got through all 200 MBE questions with a few minutes to spare and felt reasonably confident on most of them, you probably scored adequately. The MBE is graded on a curve, and "adequate" is enough to pass that section.

Compare that to your essay experience. Did you have time to fully analyze each issue? Did you finish each essay or were you rushing the last paragraph? Did you spot all the issues, or did the model answer (which you may have read after) include issues you missed entirely?

Time pressure on essays is a different kind of failure mode than time pressure on multiple choice. Multiple choice rewards quick elimination. Essays reward thorough analysis. If you struggled to fit your analysis into 30 minutes, that's a written-portion problem.

Sign 2: You Didn't Practice Essays Under Timed Conditions

Be honest. During your last bar prep, how many full MEE essays did you write under timed, closed-book conditions? Not read. Not outlined. Wrote.

If the answer is "fewer than 15," your MEE skill set probably wasn't trained.

Most commercial bar prep courses have students write maybe 10 to 20 graded essays during the entire prep period. That's not enough volume to develop the speed and pattern recognition you need. Retakers who add more essay volume in round two often see the biggest score improvements there, not on the MBE.

Sign 3: You Had Score Variance Across Essays

If you can recall feeling solid on some essays and lost on others, that's a subject-coverage gap, not a general writing problem. Common pattern: a retaker confidently handles Civil Procedure and Evidence (heavily covered by their MBE study), then bombs the Corporations or Agency essay because they barely studied those subjects.

This is especially common because the MBE doesn't test any of the four business associations subjects. Retakers who used MBE-focused study tools their first time around often have real gaps in Agency, Partnership, Corporations, and LLCs.

Why Retakers Tend to Under-Study Essays

The retaker mindset gravitates toward MBE practice for a few reasons, all of them wrong.

1. The MBE feels more measurable. You can do 50 questions, see your percentage, and feel like you're making progress. Essay practice is fuzzier. You write an essay, compare it to a model answer, and don't really know if you've improved.

2. Commercial tools are MBE-heavy. Most subscription bar prep tools focus on MBE practice because it's easier to build and easier to monetize. Essay practice tools are less common and historically more expensive.

3. Essay practice requires emotional commitment. Sitting down to write a full 30-minute essay under timed conditions is psychologically taxing. It's much easier to bang out 20 multiple-choice questions on your phone during a coffee break. Most retakers don't do enough essay reps because the reps are uncomfortable.

4. Lecture comfort food. Watching another bar prep video feels productive. Re-reading an outline feels productive. Neither builds essay-writing speed.

What Changes for Retakers Who Get This Right

Retakers who diagnose correctly and shift their study time toward essays often see dramatic score improvements in the written portion. The reason is simple: essay writing is a learnable skill, and most first-time bar takers haven't built it. By round two, with focused practice, you can move your essay scores significantly.

Compare that to MBE improvement. Once you're scoring in the 130s on the MBE, getting to 140 takes diminishing returns. Each additional point requires more practice volume. Whereas on essays, going from a 110 written score to a 130 written score is a much more achievable jump if you've never practiced essays seriously.

A Diagnostic Approach for Round Two

Before you build your study schedule, do this:

  1. Pull your score report. Note your MBE and written scores.
  2. Calculate the gap. How far below passing was each section? Which has more room to improve?
  3. Audit your last prep. How many timed essays did you write? Did you self-grade? Did you cover the four business associations subjects?
  4. Build a schedule that addresses the gap. If the written portion was the issue, allocate at least 50% of your study time to essays and the MPT.

What Essay Practice Should Look Like

For retakers, essay practice means:

The Mental Shift

The hardest part for many retakers is letting go of the assumption that the MBE was the issue. There's an emotional logic to it: the MBE was the part that felt hardest, so it must be where you failed. But the score report often tells a different story.

Trust the math. If your written score was below passing, write more essays. The score report doesn't lie even when your gut says otherwise.

Key Takeaways

Round two is your chance to fix the diagnosis. Don't refight the last war. Look at the score report and study where the points are.

If you're looking for a tool that lets you practice MEE-style essays across all eleven current subjects with self-grading rubrics, BarReps is built specifically for the retaker use case. $69.99 per month with a 7-day free trial.

Ready to change your approach?

Start with 100 free practice questions. No credit card required.

Start Studying Free